Skip to content
40Race Shoe FinderThe independent race lab

PUMA Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 v. Nike Vaporfly 4

The most aggressive geometry in the field against the most versatile — two very different ways to spend roughly the same money.

The short answer

The PUMA Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 is 14g lighter (170g against 184g), the Nike Vaporfly 4 is £5.00 cheaper at RRP (£255 against £260), and both hold their foam for roughly 240km of racing. Both are inside the World Athletics 40mm road limit.

Weight · men's US 9

Fast-R Nitro Elite 3170g
Vaporfly 4184g

Price · UK RRP

Fast-R Nitro Elite 3£260
Vaporfly 4£255

Competitive life · km before the foam fades

Fast-R Nitro Elite 3240km
Vaporfly 4240km

marks the better figure, where better is not a matter of taste

010203040503931

Fast-R Nitro Elite 339mm — road legal

010203040503529

Vaporfly 435mm — road legal

Midsoles to the same scale · mm · red dashes mark the 40mm road limit

The tape

SpecificationFast-R Nitro Elite 3Vaporfly 4
RRP£260£255 (advantage)
Weight170g (advantage)184g
Stack39 / 31mm35 / 29mm
Drop8mm6mm
Road legalyesyes
Platecarbon fibrecarbon fibre
FoamNITROFOAM EliteZoomX
Competitive life~240km~240km
Price per km of life£1.08£1.06 (advantage)
Fitstandardstandard
Underfootdemandingbalanced
Built for10K · Half · Marathon5K · 10K · Half · Marathon
Economy gain3.5–4.7%3.2–4.4%

Reading — both shoes, your race

= 5:20/km

Fast-R Nitro Elite 3

Projected
3:40:343:41:54
Saving
3:06 … −4:26
Per second
£0.30
Per race
£69
Races in the foam
~3.8

Vaporfly 4

Projected
3:40:543:42:15
Saving
2:45 … −4:06
Per second
£0.33
Per race
£67
Races in the foam
~3.8

Modelled economy gain adjusted for pace and your current shoes; ranges reflect the spread published between individual runners. Full method.

Which we would choose

RaceFor the timeFor the money
5Kat a reference 22:00Only the Vaporfly 4 is built for this distance.
10Kat a reference 45:00Fast-R Nitro Elite 3−43s to −1m 1sFast-R Nitro Elite 3cheaper per second saved
Half marathonat a reference 1:45:00Fast-R Nitro Elite 3−1m 33s to −2m 13sFast-R Nitro Elite 3cheaper per second saved
Marathonat a reference 3:45:00Fast-R Nitro Elite 3−3m 6s to −4m 26sFast-R Nitro Elite 3cheaper per second saved

Reference times, trainer baseline, whole-life economics. Your own time changes the answer — use the reading above.

The case for each

PUMA Fast-R Nitro Elite 3

The most aggressive shoe on this list. The decoupled heel and exposed plate make it feel like it is actively throwing you forward.

■ Caution That aggression cuts both ways — it is demanding on the calves and unforgiving if your form breaks down. Best suited to genuine forefoot strikers.

Nike Vaporfly 4

The most versatile super shoe on sale. Light enough for a 5K, cushioned enough for a marathon, and the fourth generation fixed the upper problems that made the VF3 divisive.

■ Caution Less cushioning than the Alphafly for a full marathon if you are on your feet over three and a half hours. Outsole rubber is minimal — treat wet corners with respect.

Straight answers

Which is lighter, the PUMA Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 or the Nike Vaporfly 4?
The PUMA Fast-R Nitro Elite 3, at 170g against 184g — a difference of 14g per shoe (men's US 9).
Which is cheaper, the PUMA Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 or the Nike Vaporfly 4?
The Nike Vaporfly 4, at £255 UK RRP against £260 — £5.00 less. Street prices move, so check the retailer for the live figure.
Are the PUMA Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 and Nike Vaporfly 4 legal for road racing?
Yes. Both measure inside the World Athletics 40mm road limit — the Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 at 39mm and the Vaporfly 4 at 35mm.

Manufacturer-stated specs unless marked estimated on the shoe sheet · last reviewed 2026-08-13 · prices are UK RRP.