The most aggressive geometry in the field against the most versatile — two very different ways to spend roughly the same money.
The short answer
The PUMA Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 is 14g lighter (170g against 184g), the Nike Vaporfly 4 is £20 cheaper at RRP (£240 against £260), and both hold their foam for roughly 240km of racing. Both are inside the World Athletics 40mm road limit.
Weight · men's US 9
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3170g
Vaporfly 4184g
0320g
Price · UK RRP
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3£260
Vaporfly 4£240
0£450
Competitive life · km before the foam fades
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3240km
Vaporfly 4240km
0700km
■ marks the better figure, where better is not a matter of taste
Both soles, one drawing3 units per mm · the line is the 40mm road limit
Fast-R Nitro Elite 340mm — on the limit
Vaporfly 435mm — road legal
The tape
manufacturer-stated · ■ the better figure, where better is not a matter of taste
The most aggressive shoe on this list. The decoupled heel and exposed plate make it feel like it is actively throwing you forward.
■ Caution That aggression cuts both ways — it is demanding on the calves and unforgiving if your form breaks down. Best suited to genuine forefoot strikers.
The most versatile super shoe on sale. Light enough for a 5K, cushioned enough for a marathon, and the fourth generation fixed the upper problems that made the VF3 divisive.
■ Caution Less cushioning than the Alphafly for a full marathon if you are on your feet over three and a half hours. Outsole rubber is minimal — treat wet corners with respect.